Are your high-draft fantasy baseball stars quietly sinking your season?

It’s Week 10, and it may be time to move on.

Welcome back to *Straight to the Chase* on the Fantasy Baseball Advice Network. In this episode, Chase Thornton breaks down the biggest fantasy baseball disappointments of the season and explains how to avoid the sunk cost fallacy that keeps managers holding underperforming stars too long.

We’re going position by position to identify which players are failing to live up to their preseason ADP, which ones are worth holding, and which fantasy baseball busts may need to be dropped or traded before they hurt your roster even more. From Cal Raleigh and Augustine Ramirez behind the plate to Vinnie Pasquantino, Josh Naylor, Jose Altuve, Bo Bichette, Fernando Tatis Jr., and Brent Rooker, Chase uses production trends, Statcast metrics, launch angle, exit velocity, injury context, and role concerns to separate real decline from possible rebound candidates.

We also cover key fantasy baseball injury updates, including Aaron Judge’s rib/bone bruise situation, Garrett Crochet’s lat strain, Corbin Burnes’ rehab setback, and positive updates on Corey Seager, Wyatt Langford, Francisco Alvarez, Max Muncy, Shane Bieber, Dylan Cease, and Max Scherzer.

Finally, we wrap with weekend matchups to exploit, including Yankees bats against left-handed pitching, Nationals hitters on the road, Braves bats at home against Pittsburgh, and streaming pitcher targets like Cade Cavalli and Martin Perez.

## Chapters

0:00 Intro and the Sunk Cost Fallacy

3:45 Catcher Analysis: Cal Raleigh and William Contreras

8:15 Augustine Ramirez and the Marlins Situation

11:30 First Base Struggles: Vinnie Pasquantino

14:50 Why It Might Be Time to Drop Josh Naylor

17:20 Middle Infield Outlook: Jose Altuve and Bo Bichette

22:00 Fernando Tatis Jr. and the Power Problem

26:15 Brent Rooker and Oblique Injury Recovery

29:00 Injury Reports: Aaron Judge and Garrett Crochet

32:30 Rehab Updates and Minor League Assignments

35:10 Weekend Matchups: Yankees vs. Red Sox

37:00 Streaming Pitchers and Braves Strategy

38:08 Outro and Final Advice

🚀 Connect With Us & Dominate Your League!

Make sure to LIKE this video, SUBSCRIBE to the channel, and turn on NOTIFICATIONS so you never miss a single update. Let us help you chase greatness all season long and crush your league mates!

🎵 Listen on the Go:

Find past episodes of *Straight to the Chase* wherever you get your podcasts! Leave us a 5-star review over at Podchaser.com.

💻 Join the Premium Community:

Head over to FSAN.com to sign up for a Pro Plus Membership and get exclusive rankings, articles, video content, and access to our exclusive troll-free, all-sports social media app, Sellout Crowds, where you can connect with fantasy experts 24/7.

🐦 Follow Chase on Twitter/X:

@STTChaseFFB

FSAN: @FSANHQ

#fantasybaseball #mlb #baseballtips #fantasyadvice #straighttothechase

Content

Tools

Connect

Shane Bieber

2026 season stats

Next Game

The Film Room

Time To Drop Your Stars? ADP Busts & Disappointments